Why I Admire Muhammad: A Response to Islamophobes

Anwar al Medina community in Dublin, Ireland @CraigCons
Anwar al Medina community in Dublin, Ireland @CraigCons

Published on Huffington Post (March 10th 2015)

Islamophobes have attacked me because I’ve written positively about Muhammad, the Prophet of Islam. Because I am a Catholic, they consider me to be a heretic and feel that my interfaith activities are sacrilegious. Islam, to these critics, is evil and Muhammad is nothing but a terrorist. I see Muhammad very differently from these fanatics. This short piece highlights his exemplary character and challenges Islamophobes to think differently about the Prophet.

One reason why I admire Muhammad is that he was an advocate of equality. In his Last Sermon at Mount Arafat, he declared: “An Arab has no superiority over a non-Arab, nor a non-Arab has any superiority over an Arab… a white person has no superiority over black nor does a black have any superiority over white except by piety and good action.” The Prophet’s sermon ensured freedom for all people in society. His democratic message could be seen as a precursor to the American Constitution, which stands for similar egalitarian values, and to the pluralist outlook of the Founding Fathers, such as George Washington and Benjamin Franklin.

I also admire Prophet Muhammad because he advocated for religious tolerance, particularly towards Jews and Christians. In the Treaty of Maqnah, the Prophet told followers of Judaism that “[you] may be in peace… you are in security [under my rule]… Towards you is no wrong and no enmity.” As in his relations with the Jews, Muhammad wanted to protect Christians, who are also considered to be revered people to Muslims. In a covenant he made with Christian monks at Mount Sinai, Muhammad ensured the monks that Christian judges would be protected and churches preserved. The words of the covenant state that Muslims should look to Jews and Christians as their brothers and sisters who are children of the Almighty. In light of these treaties and covenants, the recent attacks by the Islamic State against religious minorities in Syria and Iraq are particularly striking because they blatantly contradict the Prophet’s call for tolerance within the Abrahamic tradition.

By extending religious tolerance to non-Muslims, Muhammad stood for human rights. The Prophet wanted women to have liberty so that they could live the kind of life that they desire. Two of his closest female companions demonstrate this point. His first wife, Khadija, was a successful merchant who ran a thriving caravan trade. Another of the Prophet’s wives, Aisha, became a leading Muslim scholar and jurist who was the first ever-female scholar of Islam. The relationship that he had with his wives showed that the Prophet believed that women should take leading roles in society and partake in important matters related to law and politics. The integration of these women into Arab society demonstrates that Muhammad did not want women to live in isolation, but rather he wanted them to become active members of society.

Smaller things outside of equality, religious tolerance and human rights also make me appreciate Prophet Muhammad. The Quran, as revealed to Muhammad, tells Muslims not to defame or be sarcastic towards other people. The Prophet believed that name-calling was wicked and he encouraged his followers to be civil in their interactions with others. He also taught us the importance of humility, and he encouraged Muslims and non-Muslims to be humble and pray.

The Islamophobes who do not see the value in Muhammad’s qualities are simply being close-minded. If the Prophet were alive, he would show them mercy and compassion in spite of their actions. He would also tell them to seek more knowledge.

6 thoughts on “Why I Admire Muhammad: A Response to Islamophobes

  1. I agree that those who do not see the benovelence of the holy Prophet Mohammad (pbuh) simply don’t want to see the flawlessness in his character. He was indeed a supereem being who was very successful in both religion and secular world. It’s be cause of him that we today can contribute to our society with equality, fresh appraisal and show appreciation for his teachings of tolerance and compassion.


  2. Very well said. I agree, it was prophet muhammad that gave women their rights in a time when the birth of a girl was considered horrific. He sets a supreme example for everyone to follow and act upon. Islamophobics should pray that may god help them open up their narrow minds and overcome their lack of knowledge before basing judgements on the perfect man who showed religious tolerance, compassion, mercy, and love for all humanity.


  3. I wonder if it would make any difference to Dr Considine’s view on Mohammed if he found out that the part of the last sermon which he quotes is a modern invention which originated in a 1987 book “The Sermons of the Prophet” by S.F.H Faizi.

    As for Mohammed’s wives, Khadija was a successful business woman before Islam came into being and supposedly gave women greater rights than previously.

    Let’s spare a thought for Safiyah too. Mohammed had her husband Kinana tortured to death then took her as booty.


    1. Many of the historical accounts about Prophet Muhammad’s (s) supposed gratuitous violence (e.g. the incident you have mentioned above) were fabrications compiled under the illegitimate and violent Abbasid caliphate that sought to justify its violations and excesses. You need to do a careful examination of narrators, who, opposed to the equal rights that Islam brought, and wanting to maintain their previous tribal superiority and dominance, were liberal in their defamation of his character.


    2. I am surprised by your revelation about last sermon of the propht, as per your comment it invented in 1987 by some auther -in reality its in Sahi Bukhari and Sahi Muslim with multiple chain of narrations, both are over 1000 years old books- Amazingly, I read it in 1985 prior to the publication of so-called innovative book by Mr Faizi, as you refered.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s